Saturday, April 5, 2014

《未夠秤》


一說到年輕人,香港總有些人,條件反射撲出來罵。

鵪鶉的,罵;敢言的,又罵。無理想,罵;有理想,又罵。說話未夠成熟的,罵你無知;說話有理有據的,就話你受政治勢力控制。

看紀錄片《未夠秤》,你大概就明白,這群年輕人是不可能受任何人「控制」的。

片中紀錄兩主角,一是學民思潮的黃之鋒、一是社民連的馬雲褀;一個鋒芒畢露走在最前、一個默默耕耘,當社會運動的後勤部隊。紀錄片裡,兩人崗位不同,但在大環境中,互相補足,折射社會運動的兩面。

有幸在電台節目中,很早已有機會接觸學民思潮及社民連的成員。學民的同學們,出得大場面的,個個思路清晰,說話有佐證,又不會長篇大論,難怪很多考DSE的同學們憂心,中文科口試小組討論時,遇上黃之鋒怎麼辦。社民連等人在主流電視鏡頭前,只見其「激進」一面,事實上很多都是讀書人,文史哲常識琅琅上口,唔係講笑,勝過好多大枝嘢政客。

《未夠秤》一片,機緣巧合,從黃之鋒仍是一寂寂無聞14歲學生時,已開始跟進拍攝,他們一群年輕人堅毅不屈,最終阻止國民教育推行,是香港近十年來社運裡罕見的「成功爭取」。對很多有份參與這場運動的朋友而言,片中場景可能熟口熟面,紀錄片較有趣一面,是兩人平日與人溝通交流的細節。有一回,黃之鋒在街頭遇上關心他的陌生途人。

阿叔問他:「你又高了……你平日多做運動嗎?」

黃之鋒:「我不做運動……我做社會運動。」(補註:行家報料,呢位咁關心黃之鋒身體的阿叔,絕非普通阿叔,係港島區警察公共關係科一位阿sir)

《未夠秤》導演、英國人Matthew Torne和香港有點淵源,2003年他在香港,經歷了沙士與七一大遊行,後來想拍關於香港的故事。製作團隊說,前期搜集資料時,見過很多政界人士,最後還是覺得這兩位年輕人更有趣。

中大博群電影節中,Torne影後座談,他覺得,香港的社會運動其實非常溫和,所謂激進,只是推推鐵馬,不算什麼,社民連還要參加立法會選舉,簡直是沒有什麼可以更溫和。

Torne說,他最近來到香港,覺得地鐵裡的「忠告」很有趣,不斷提醒人「地面濕滑,小心行路」或「上扶手電梯時,不要用手提電話」等說話,一直把人當細路。他認為,殖民管治一直都是這種手法,英國人如是,今天共產黨也一樣,不斷告訴人︰你們政治冷感,參與政治無用,你們是孩子,我是父母官,上面還有阿爺。

執筆之時,剛好看到是日《明報》頭條,〈基本法研討會變宴會〉,宣傳基本法,就係飲飲食食,用的是公帑,權貴們不只當大家係細路,還以為大家是貪吃的豬,權貴們睇準了人性的弱點,飲飲食食蛇齋餅糉,照顧人最低層次的慾望,動不動就說「亂」、「影響經濟」、「冇啖好食」,出言恐嚇,習非成是,荒謬絕倫,但就係日復一日發生。

《未夠秤》一片,主角馬雲褀與黃之鋒最後一句:講醒覺,講堅持。

醒覺,讓大家明瞭權貴的陰招;堅持,讓我們清楚知道,舊日所相信的價值不必接受時代糟蹋,困難重重,我們就鬥長命。

學民思潮很多同學們,正在考文憑試,這個社會並不仁慈,大學收生也絕不仁慈。關鍵時刻,請暫時把醒覺與堅持,留給自己,祝一切順利。

***   ***   ***
反國教相關文章:

(國教運動之後,有些人才跑出來說,運動「口號太簡化」等等,他們都忘了,每句口號,背後都有理據。再看看今天,那些「國民教育中心」竟還未能再重新招標,你就知道當日招標,私相授受,有幾多不見得光的問題。)

***   ***   ***

中大博群電影節尾聲了,最後一場,是At Berkeley,大學校園紀實,長四小時的紀錄片,談經費大減下大學如何維持辦學理念,很適合香港今天學界參詳,原版連英文字幕都無,今次版本,不惜工本,新加英文字幕。(播映時間,8/4 星期二,中大伍宜孫書院演藝室)

 

38 comments:

  1. "Torne說,他最近來到香港,覺得地鐵裡的「忠告」很有趣,不斷提醒人「地面濕滑,小心行路」或「上扶手電梯時,不要用手提電話」等說話,一直把人當細路。"

    佢留意到唔代表人人留意到,自私嘅人,社會有好多老弱傷殘,不懂照顧別人

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I feel the same as well every time i go back to hk... People of hk have been pampered too much....

      Delete
    2. By the way,「上扶手電梯時,不要用手提電話」 what is this??

      Delete
    3. 這句是叫人上落電梯時,不要掛住玩手機,具體用字不記得了,好多站都聽到,好煩。

      Delete
    4. 地鐵咁做,也可能係怕人出事時投訴,自己先隆重警告而試圖免責。

      Delete
    5. 其實我哋可唔可以先投訴地铁喺度不斷制噪音, 影响搭客心情.......日日都要搭地铁, 實在煩到飛起! 其實怕投訴, 喺電梯口貼啲提示便得啦, 使唔使日嘈夜嘈? 再者, 有呢啲提示噪音, 都唔見啲人有乜嘢反應, 低頭ge依然低頭, 阻人ge依然阻人, 一啲作用都冇.....

      Delete
    6. 盲人甘點呀?又睇告示呀?

      Delete
    7. 儍的嗎? 失明人士會邊行邊低頭打手機嗎? 不要為反區生而反, 用點常識吧!

      Delete
    8. 「地面濕滑,小心行路」你有無睇篇文?

      Delete
    9. 「上扶手電梯時,不要用手提電話」盲不能用手機嗎?

      Delete
  2. ”看紀錄片《未夠秤》,你大概就明白,這群年輕人是不可能受任何人「控制」的。”

    的確不受控,out of control

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 樣樣受控, 政府就可以得其所哉: 自由自在想點就點, 咁先叫做"不受控"!

      Delete
    2. 好似你似不受控多d,成日想阻政府,浪費纳税人$

      Delete
    3. 好多爭取都係為左幫納稅人慳錢架, 例如高鐵

      Delete
    4. 而家咁多冇用既高官, 至最浪費納稅人既錢!

      Delete
    5. 阻政府 = 浪費纳税人$? 政府唔會亂用公帑? 奴才思維的確令人大開眼界

      Delete
    6. 港珠澳橋,高鐵,焚化爐,推填區,夠味?

      Delete
    7. I agree much preciois money is wasted by prolonged procedure triggered by pan democrats

      Delete
    8. Oh yea, so let those pro governments/Chinas do whatever they want...

      Oh do you remember how come we need to build so many things now instead of the mid or late 90s? Who stopped or decrease the scale of all those projects?

      And please don't forget that the Shatin-Central Line that MTR should complete in 2012 was being postponed by the sudden urgent construction need for the High Speed Rail Link to China, which is still incomplete and benefit no one from the huge traffic jams nowadays. And let's not forget MTR original plans of changing trains and signalling equipment was being postponed by this also, which we can foresee more train problems due to aging railway, which all caused by the XRL.

      And how are you going to explain to people living in TKO and Tuen Mun about the land refill sites? Are those people less equal than you do? Isn't it not too long time ago someone in the highest position promised that we have capacity for recycling and land filling?

      Oh the bridge? Is that really a huge need for HK to link up with Zhuhai by road? We all got the answer.

      Oh yes, let the government and the pro-government/China do what they want.......and you got your 5 cents

      That's great.

      Delete
    9. irrational, what we needed should be needed. Face to the reality. You do not desire doesnt mean noone desire. Land refill sites must be built, they are equal people but needed is needed. Irrational......sigh

      Delete
    10. Irrational....I agree with you

      Delete
    11. 係呀,太多人乜都犯反政府,歡迎多些人說真相正視聽,尤其區生都是這樣,歡迎纠正,避免錯誤思想印入無知的讀者

      Delete
    12. 同感brother

      Delete
    13. Irrational?

      Years ago the Brits has calculated the demand for the West Rail and stated it's station must be built in West Kowloon, which was being considered as "irrational" by China. What happen now?

      And do you know who's the rational person that told/promised others the land fill projects can be stopped? The CEO of the HKSAR.

      Rational? Who told the British Hong Kong government to shrink the size of the new airport together with other land reclamation project which was being considered for future growth of business and population? The rational Chinese government and the pro-China parties in Hong Kong.

      So, what's your rational thinking? "Rational same person"?

      Delete
    14. You mean that "And how are you going to explain to people living in TKO and Tuen Mun about the land refill sites? Are those people less equal than you do?"

      And now I tell you "What should be needed to be needed. "

      Delete
    15. What should really be needed to be needed, but by doing the right things in the right way, under the surveillance of the legislative council.

      What should be needed to be needed, yes, so the land reclamation to build a man-made island near Mui Wo should be done, the cross harbour link between lantau and Kennedy Town should be built, the expansion of the airport should be done, all suggested by the British Hong Kong government, rejected by the China government, are now being pushed ahead again, and let's not mention dozens of other projects also.

      What should be needed to be needed, what a good say.

      Delete
    16. Anyway, now you gain that sometimes government did wrong and sometimes political parties did wrong. I hope peoplewho want to blame dont put all responsibilities to government and less sarcastic in talking. It is of no help in discussion.

      Delete
    17. Yes, but if we don't discuss or discussion is not allowed, we will not even know if it's wrong or not until something very wrong comes.

      We do need discussion, we do need opposition. Discussion provide clearer view for people, opposition provides people different angle of view, instead of telling us "trust us, the government won't lie to you".

      Delete
    18. 廢話,打倒反政府廢青!

      Delete
    19. All anti-governments are youngsters? You are so interesting

      Delete
    20. 社會渣滓始終都係社會渣滓, 一發現唔夠理據就求其打句 "打倒反政府廢青" , 拉低唒D討論水平

      Delete
    21. 即係狗囉

      Delete
  3. 區先生說反國教「成功爭取」,隨時會畀人罵「左膠」的。 :P

    現在很多人的心態,我真的不知該如何形容。被迫到神經質固然是共產黨的錯,不過恐怕未去到函谷關之前,六國軍隊就已經自己打起來。不要說合作進軍,就連各自行動都不成。

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 「成功爭取」都要被罵左膠?

      //六國軍隊就已經自己打起來。不要說合作進軍,就連各自行動都不成。//
      你睇政改諮詢咁耐,建制派半個方案都冇,正是袖手旁觀,等你地自己打死佢,高招。

      Delete
    2. 區先生可能沒特別留意了。當初宣佈散場已被人鬧了一次,現在我的網友還在罵,說制止了強制課程根本說不上「成功」或「勝利」,因為政府還是可以在學校無孔不入地滲透。

      他們似乎忘了在大家未反國教之前,政府早就在滲透,引爆點在強推課程。那麼阻止了強推,又怎能不算有部分成功了呢﹖

      Delete
  4. 97前,我(不是港人)從加拿大來香港工作,曾與一同事(港人)閒談,說:香港人示威太溫和,沒效果。看看南韓人是如何爭取權益和民主。他笑著問:要我們學南韓嗎?回答:你們自己決定啦。

    ReplyDelete
  5. 從你談及 Torne在香港的觀察得到啓發,謝謝。
    啓發記錄詳見 https://www.facebook.com/ariav23665965

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 謝謝,香港的地鐵扶手電梯,以前是叫左行右企,現在是叫人「企定定」,扶手電梯上不要走動了。

      Delete